Settlement agreements: when does settlement really bring an end to a dispute?

Articles  |   18 November 2026

Written by
Rachel McGee, Solicitor

Settlement agreements are commonly used to record that a dispute has been resolved and bring legal claims to an end on agreed terms. But does resolving one claim also prevent further claims arising? A recent High Court case United Living (South) Limited v Dovista UK Limited & Others [2026] EWHC 2676 (TCC). highlights the importance of carefully drafted settlement agreements. In this case, the Court considered whether a settlement agreement prevented a party from pursuing further claims arising out of the same construction project.

Background and the Court’s decision

The dispute arose from a construction project involving the conversion of a building in London. United Living (South) Limited (“United Living”), the main contractor, had previously brought proceedings against several parties, including the project’s architect, Hawkins Brown Limited (“Hawkins Brown”) in connection with alleged defects in the building. These proceedings were settled in March 2023, with Hawkins Brown agreeing to pay £1.575 million as part of the settlement. United Living brought a further claim concerning the same construction project in July 2024. Hawkins Brown applied to strike out the proceedings on two grounds: that the March 2023 settlement agreement had already resolved the claim, and that pursuing it amounted to an abuse of process. The High Court rejected the application. The Court considered the wording of the settlement agreement and concluded that it was a settlement of a particular claim and not a general release between the parties. In other words, the terms of the agreement released only the claim in question and did not prevent the parties from pursuing unrelated claims arising outside its scope. Crucially, the agreement referred to a specifically defined “Dispute” rather than expressly releasing all claims between the parties arising from the construction project. The Court also rejected Hawkins Brown’s argument that the further proceedings amounted to an abuse of process. The fact that United Living could have brought the claims earlier did not mean that it should have done so. The later claims raised distinct issues, and, at the time of settlement, the potential further claim still required substantial investigation. This was not a ruling that Hawkins Brown was liable for the alleged defects. It simply allowed the claims to proceed.

What does this mean for businesses or individuals entering into a settlement agreement?

The practical question is to ask: what claim (or potential claim) is being brought to an end? A reference to “full and final settlement” may leave room for disagreement if the dispute itself is defined too narrowly or imprecisely. Equally, a party intending to settle only identified claims will want to avoid inadvertently agreeing a much wider release. Parties should carefully consider what claims they wish to settle. As the Court will consider the precise wording of the agreement, the wording should accurately reflect the parties’ intensions. If the parties wish to settle all current and future claims, this should be recorded correctly, or it may inadvertently leave future disputes on the table. As shown in the recent High Court decision, the wording of a settlement agreement can have significant and lasting consequences. Obtaining legal advice at an early stage can help ensure that any settlement agreement accurately reflects the parties’ intentions and provides the appropriate level of protection against future claims. 

The key takeaway

The High Court decision is a reminder that entering into a settlement agreement does not necessarily mean finality to a dispute. Although settlement agreements are an effective way to resolve a dispute, the effectiveness of any agreements depends on its precise wording.

If you're looking for tailored advice on drafting, reviewing, and negotiating settlement terms, please get in touch with Rachel McGee on 020 8663 4137, or anyone in our Dispute Resolution team to book a consultation. 

Related News & Insights